Otherworldly, seemingly omnipresent, and a bit odd. She's eager to befriend Betty, and is surprisingly insightful for her age, but may be hiding dark secrets about herself.
Evelyn introduces herself to Betty Cooper while in the Blue and Gold offices. She explains that they almost met through Alice and Polly, who are in cahoots with Evelyn's father, Edgar Evernever. Evelyn explains that she now attends Riverdale High School, and that she stopped by to greet her and inform Betty that she won't tell anyone about her seizure from the other night. As it turns out, Evelyn was present during Betty's incident. She and her father were invited over by Alice for a cookout and to burn a few of her things. Evelyn then inquires about Betty, who excuses herself to visit Ben Button in the hospital. Later, Evelyn watches from the door way eerily as Betty and Jughead tend to a seizing Ethel Muggs, Betty visibly disturbed by Evelyn who is simply watching.
- In the Little Archie comics, which features many of the Archie Comics characters as grade school children, Evelyn was a shy girl who was acquainted with Archie and his friends. However, her only real friend was her doll, Minerva.
- Evelyn reappears in an issue of Betty & Veronica Spectacular to kidnap Archie.
- See also: Category:Images of Evelyn Evernever